Are you wondering about the Meat Delivery Subscription – ButcherBox? Is it worth the money? Where does the meat come from? How does it work? If so, you’ve come to the right place! We answer those questions and a whole lot more. Plus, we review our experience as a ButcherBox customer stocking our freezer. This post contains affiliate links. All views are our own.
Also, we have a special offer that you don’t want to miss, so be sure to check it out before leaving!
What is ButcherBox?
Butcher Box is a meat subscription box that gets delivered to your home. They offer curated boxes of pre-selected meats or a custom mix of Grass-Fed Beef, Free Range Chicken, Heritage Pork, Wild Caught Seafood, and even ground turkey or bison.
The ButcherBox company is located in Boston, MA. Their meats are sourced from carefully vetted locations throughout the world, which we’ll explain below.
Plan Options
ButcherBox has a good variety of different plans and meat options.
You can choose your meats, different box sizes, and different shipping frequencies. Let me explain…
You have the choice of five (5) different boxes and each box has two (2) different size options. See the table below to see each option and its associated costs: Shipping is free.
| Box Type | What’s Inside | How Much Meat | Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Custom | Your choice of beef, chicken, pork, and seafood | Classic Box = 9-14 lbs Big Box = 18-26 lbs | Classic Box = $169 Big Box = $306 |
| Mixed Box | A mix of beef, chicken, and pork | Classic Box = 8-11 lbs Big Box = 16-22 lbs | Classic Box = $146 Big Box = $269 |
| Beef and Chicken | A mix of beef and chicken | Classic Box = 8-11 lbs Big Box = 16-22 lbs | Classic Box = $146 Big Box = $269 |
| Beef and Pork | A mix of beef and pork | Classic Box = 8-11 lbs Big Box = 16-22 lbs | Classic Box = $146 Big Box = $269 |
| All Beef | Beef only | Classic Box = 8-11 lbs Big Box = 16-22 lbs | Classic Box = $146 Big Box = $269 |
How Does the Subscription Work?
You do need a subscription to order from ButcherBox. Fortunately, the subscription plans are easy to understand and easy to get started with.
First, you pick your box and box size. After that, you choose how often they’ll ship your meats in dry ice to your house.
The default shipment frequency is 4 weeks (once per month). However, they offer four (4) different shipment frequencies to choose from:
- 2 Weeks;
- 4 Weeks;
- 6 Weeks; or
- 8 Weeks.
If you want your boxes to arrive more or less frequently, you can change it from 4 weeks during sign-up.
If you’re already subscribed, you can change your box frequency in your ButcherBox account settings. We have our box shipped to us every 4 weeks and it works well for our meal schedule.
Stress-Free Subscription Changes
We like how ButcherBox makes it easy to make changes to the subscription plans. You can make the following changes right from the account portal:
- Your bill date;
- Box shipment frequency;
- Box size and meats; and
- Shipping or billing info.
You can also easily pause or cancel your subscription without any hidden fees or penalties. They don’t pressure you at all to keep your subscription if you’re not happy.
You simply visit their website and enter your email to claim your Free Chicken Nuggets For Life offer.
Stress-Free Subscription Changes
We like how ButcherBox makes it easy to make changes to the subscription plans. You can make the following changes right from the account portal:
- Your bill date;
- Box shipment frequency;
- Box size and meats; and
- Shipping or billing info.
You can also easily pause or cancel your subscription without any hidden fees or penalties. They don’t pressure you at all to keep your subscription if you’re not happy.
You simply visit their website and enter your email to claim your Free Chicken Nuggets For Life offer.
About the Meat
One of the most important considerations we make when choosing the kinds of food we put in our bodies is where it comes from. In our opinion, the top-selling points for ButcherBox are the fact that all of their meat comes from carefully vetted locations, is fed natural diets, and is raised humanely.
The Beef
The beef is 100% grass-fed and grass-finished. The majority of it comes from Australia where the climate is ideal and the animals spend their entire lives grazing on pastureland.
All beef regardless of where it’s sourced from is pasture-raised, humanely raised, 100% grass-fed and finished, and never given antibiotics or added hormones.
Cuts include ribeye, flat iron, bottom round roast, culotte, chuck roast, steak tips, filet mignon, and ground beef.
The Chicken
The chicken is free-range organic and is Global Animal Partnership (GAP 3) certified. This means that the chickens are not raised in cages, crates, or overcrowded environments. They have seasonal access to the outdoors and get plenty of fresh air. All of these living enhancements greatly increase the quality of life for these chickens.
Also, the chickens are never given antibiotics or added hormones!
Cuts include drumsticks, tenders, chicken breasts, chicken thighs (boneless and bone-in), and whole chicken.
The Pork
Many of their pork products have lineage to heritage breeds like Berkshire, Duroc, and Chester White. Heritage breed pork basically means that the hogs have a distinguished, natural ancestry. They mature slower and their meat develops a delicious marbling and flavor.
All hogs are raised crate-free and are fed an all-vegetarian diet. Plus, they’re never given antibiotics or added hormones.
Cuts include bacon, butt, pork chops, ribs, pork tenderloin, sausages, breakfast sausage, and ground.
The Seafood
ButcherBox offers a variety of different wild-caught seafood like Salmon, Scallops, Lobster, Cod, and Halibut. Some of it is seasonal however and based on availability.
- The Sockeye Salmon is wild-caught in Alaska.
- Scallops are caught in Georges Bank (the Atlantic Ocean off the Massachusetts coast) and landed in New Bedford, MA.
- Lobsters are caught off the coast of Maine.
- The Cod and Halibut are caught in the Gulf of Alaska and the Bearing Sea.
Is It Worth the Money?
Now that we’ve explained what ButcherBox is, the plans, how it works, and its meats, it’s time to answer the big question – Is ButcherBox worth the money?
To answer that question, let’s break down the numbers:
As an example, we’ll use the standard-size mixed box being shipped every 4-weeks.
- The cost of a standard mixed box is $146. This contains 8.5-11 lbs of meat, so we’ll average it to 9.5 lbs.
- If you figure 24 meals (10-12 for 2 people / 5-6 for 4 people) per month and 6 oz of meat per meal, this plan equals $6.08 per meal.
- The cost is $15.37 per pound.
For high-quality meat, it’s worth it in our opinion.
Here’s the breakdown in cost per pound for each option:
| Box Type | Standard Box Avg. Cost/lb. | Big Box Avg. Cost/lb. |
|---|---|---|
| Custom Box | $15.37 | $13.91 |
| All Other Boxes | $14.42 | $14.16 |
The best option based on cost is the Big Custom Box at an average of $13.91 per pound.
Is ButcherBox a Good Deal?
Everybody has their own opinion of what’s a good deal and what’s not. Therefore, we can only share our opinion based on our experience. And in our opinion, ButcherBox is a good deal! Here’s why…
If you’re fortunate enough to sign up with a promo like Free Chicken Nuggets For Life, you’ll receive one pack of their Gluten Free Chicken Nuggets with every order for the life of your membership!
Another thing to keep in mind is that all of the boxes include free shipping. As a result, the price for a box is the price you pay with it delivered to your door.
How Much Does ButcherBox Cost Per Month?
ButcherBox offers a variety of subscription plans that range from $146 to $306 per month. The most popular plan is the Classic Box, which contains 10-14 lbs of premium grass-fed, pasture-raised and free-range meats for just $146/month or an equivalent value of ~$260 if purchased separately. This plan also includes free shipping and a bonus item each month. *Please note, prices do change!
If you are looking for more variety, the Custom Box offers 18-26 lbs of proteins for $306/month or an equivalent value of ~$470 if purchased separately. All plans include a 100% satisfaction guarantee and exclusive member discounts.
Additionally, customers can add extras like high-quality seafood, wild-caught Alaskan salmon, and organic chicken to their plan. With ButcherBox, you can trust that you are getting the highest quality proteins at an affordable price. No matter which subscription plan you choose, you will always enjoy free shipping and unbeatable groceries value!
Meat Taste and Quality
One of the main reasons we love ButcherBox is its consistently high-quality meat. You’ll notice the great taste and quality the first time you try one of their meats.
Note: if you’re used to eating grain-fed beef, you’ll notice that the 100% grass-fed, grass-finished beef tastes a little different. That’s because grass-fed beef tends to be leaner and has a more distinct beef flavor. This is totally normal and is how beef is actually supposed to taste!
Video Review
Watch our video review to see one of our Beef Only boxes.
ButcherBox Promo
If you’re considering a ButcherBox membership, you’ll be glad to know that they’re currently running a special offer of Free Chicken Nuggets For Life (valid for new customers through 3/13. That means you’ll continue to receive one pack of Gluten-Free Chicken Nuggets with every box that’s delivered to your door for as long as you keep your membership.
You can find that promo by visiting ButcherBox’s website and entering your email address.
How to Cancel Butcherbox
Need a break from your subscription? I get it! Sometimes finances don’t work out! Canceling your ButcherBox subscription is easy. Here are the steps you need to take:
1. Log into your account on ButcherBox’s website and click ‘My Subscription’.
2. Find the “Cancel Subscription” section and click it.
3. Scroll down and click “Confirm Cancellation”, located at the bottom of the page.
4. A confirmation message will appear confirming that your subscription has been canceled successfully.
5. You should receive a confirmation email within 24 hours with additional instructions and information about the cancellation process, including any fees associated with canceling your subscription early or changes to any remaining orders in progress at the time of cancellation.
Keep in mind that you may still be charged for any orders already placed, even if you cancel your subscription before the order is shipped. Additionally, if you signed up for an annual plan and are canceling prior to its expiration date, there may be a cancellation fee associated with the remaining months of service.
If you have any further questions about canceling your ButcherBox subscription, please contact their customer service team directly. They would be more than happy to help! Good luck!
Final Thoughts
We confidently recommend ButcherBox to all of our friends and family because of its quality, convenience, cost, and positive environmental policies.
I hope you learned what ButcherBox is, how it works, its options, its cost, and its quality. I also hope we answered all of your questions and helped you to make an informed decision about whether or not to try it for yourself.
We’ll be working on recipes using ButcherBox meats that you don’t want to miss, so be sure to sign up for our email newsletter to stay up-to-date on all of our creations!
If you have any other questions or want to share your experience, please comment below and we’ll do our best to answer you.
Filet mignon no longer available beginning January 2022. I don’t know if that’s temporary or permanent as they didn’t specify. Was told to choose something else.
I’m very disappointed as it was one of my favorite cuts and it helped offset the price per pound for me. Otherwise I’m very happy with their other meats and add-ons – the quality is definitely there!
I have been using butcher box for the last few years with n problem. In the last few orders the chicken has not been properly vacuum sealed and I have had to throw out about 5# of chicken. Their customer service response left an additional bad taste in my mouth. I am now looking for alternatives.
How about lamd
Hi, they do not at this time!