The 15 Best Cookies for Your Holiday Cookie Trays

Discover 15 easy, no-fail Christmas cookie recipes perfect for gifting & your holiday cookie tray! Includes Chewy Gingerbread, Pistachio Pudding Cookies, and clever money-saving tips.

Every great holiday party deserves a showstopping Christmas cookie tray! Imagine a platter stacked high with vibrant colors, irresistible textures, and classic holiday flavors—that’s the magic you’ll create with these 15 best Christmas cookie recipes. We’ve assembled the perfect mix for success: sturdy shortbread cut-outs that travel without breaking, super-chewy Gingerbread for perfect presentation, and ultra-easy, 3-Ingredient Peanut Butter Cookies for those busy nights. Stop searching and start baking—your perfect cookie array begins right here!

The Quick & Easy Winners

These recipes are your secret weapon for quickly filling your platter when time is tight.

1. Easy Cake Mix Christmas Cookies: Start with a box of cake mix (any flavor!) for the easiest, fluffiest cookies. They’re a budget-friendly option and perfectly chewy.
2. Super Easy 3-Ingredient Peanut Butter Christmas Cookies: An absolute classic! All you need is peanut butter, sugar, and an egg. They bake up perfectly soft and are naturally gluten-free.
3. Whip Up Bakery-Style Thick Chocolate Chip Cookies – No Waiting, No Spreading!: Skip the chilling time! This recipe delivers those desirable tall, thick, bakery-style cookies without the wait, making them ideal for last-minute baking.
4. 5 Minute Ornament Cookies DIY: These use pre-made cookies and a candy ROLO to turn into a colorful “ornament.” They are quick, fun, and impressive for kids and adults alike.

Texture & Flavor Favorites

These recipes offer unique flavors and textures that stand out on any tray.

5. The Chewiest Gingerbread Cookies Ever: The perfect texture is key here—chewy, not crunchy. These spicy-sweet cookies hold their shape perfectly and are a holiday staple.
6. Soft, Fluffy Pistachio Pudding Cookies: The secret ingredient is instant pistachio pudding mix, which gives these cookies a delicate green hue, a soft crumb, and a unique, nutty flavor.
7. Chewy Cherry Chocolate Chip Cookies: A festive twist on the classic. The burst of tart dried cherries mixed with rich chocolate chips makes these cookies taste distinctly like the holidays.
8. M&M Cookies with Shortening: Using shortening instead of all butter helps these cookies maintain a beautifully soft texture while preventing excessive spreading, making them great for stacking.
9. The Best Chewy Fruitcake Cookies: All the great flavor of fruitcake (candied fruit, nuts, warm spices) in a small, dense, chewy cookie form. No one can resist this bite-sized version of the holiday classic.

Perfect for Customization & Gifting

These cookies are structurally sound and excellent bases for holiday decoration and personalization.

10. Christmas Cut Out Shortbread Sprinkle Cookies: A sturdy, buttery shortbread base that holds its shape for intricate cutters. Decorate them simply with festive sprinkles before baking for an easy, traditional look.
11. Christmas Vanilla Pudding Cookies: Adding vanilla instant pudding mix results in an incredibly soft and moist cookie that stays fresh for days—perfect for advance gifting!
12. No-Chill Chocolate Chip Christmas Cookies: This dough is engineered to be rolled and baked immediately. It’s a great standard chocolate chip base that can be topped with red and green sprinkles before baking.
13. Peppermint White Chocolate Pudding Cookies: The cool mint flavor and the creamy white chocolate create a beautiful flavor profile. The addition of pudding mix keeps them soft, and the crushed peppermint makes them instantly festive.
14. No-Spread REESE’S PIECES Chocolate Chip Cookies: These are designed to stay thick and full of peanut butter cups and chocolate. Their lack of spread makes them reliably uniform, which is wonderful for stacking in gift boxes.
15. Salted Butterscotch Pretzel Cookies: A superb sweet-and-salty combination! The crunchy pretzel pieces and creamy butterscotch chips make for a complex and addictive cookie that stands out from all the chocolate.

---

🎁 Why These Cookies Are Perfect for Cookie Trays

The secret to a great cookie tray is variety, stability, and longevity. These recipes check all the boxes:

• They Stack Well: Many of these recipes—especially the pudding cookies, shortbread, and M&M cookies—are designed to be thick and sturdy. This prevents breakage and makes them easy to arrange in towers or layers within a tin.
• Contrasting Colors & Shapes:
• Your tray needs visual appeal!
• The Pistachio Pudding Cookies (green), Cherry Chocolate Chip (red), Gingerbread (brown), and Peppermint Bark (white and red) offer a beautiful, festive color palette.
• Excellent Shelf Life: Recipes that use shortening or pudding mix tend to stay soft and fresh longer than those made with only butter. This means you can bake them days in advance of your event or gifting day.
• No-Fuss Transport: Unlike fragile royal-icing decorated cookies or gooey bar recipes, these cookies are robust enough to handle the journey to a cookie swap without damage.

---

💰 Sweet Savings: Tips to Make Your Holiday Cookie Trays on a Budget

Baking cookies this holiday season might sound expensive, but with a few smart strategies, you can minimize the cost and maximize the fun for your holiday cookie trays:

• Hit the Post-Holiday Clearance: The day after Christmas is the absolute best time to stock up on baking essentials like sprinkles, M&Ms, peppermint candy, and food coloring. These items are drastically discounted and keep perfectly until next year.
• Buy Bulk, Store Smart: The main expense in baking is often nuts and chocolate chips. Buy large bags of pecans or walnuts and chocolate chips now, and store the extras in your freezer to keep them fresh until you need them.
• Use Store-Brand Essentials: For items that don’t affect the final flavor profile—like sugar, flour, eggs, and vegetable shortening—opt for the store-brand version. The savings add up when you’re baking large quantities.
• Embrace the Cake Mix: The Easy Cake Mix Cookies are your most economical option! A single box of mix is inexpensive and yields a large batch of delicious cookies.
• Swap for Dried Fruit: Dried cherries and other candied fruits are often cheaper than specialty baking chips or high-end chocolate. They provide a beautiful color and a great chewy texture at a lower cost.
• The Freezer is Your Friend: To avoid wasting ingredients, make large batches of the dough (like the No-Chill Chocolate Chip or Shortbread dough), form them into logs, and freeze them. Then, you can slice and bake exactly as many as you need, preventing any baked cookies from going stale.

With these recipes and money-saving tips, your holiday baking will be a stress-free success! Which recipe will you bake first for your holiday cookie trays?